What a week for Irish dancing in the news! I am referring, of course, to the recent controversy surrounding an incendiary article published on IrishCentral.com, "Why Irish Dancing Has Lost its Way and Needs to Change." This firestorm appears to have, in part, been touched off by recent changes in costume control issued by An Coimisiún. It would seem that the article's author, Cahir O'Doherty, seized upon an opportunity to wade into some pretty muddy waters and nearly drowned himself in a deluge of angry criticism.
I've been researching Irish dance costumes for over five years now and been dancing, off and on, since 1987. I've talked a lot about the major changes in costumes which have occurred in the last twenty years. As a phenomena, it is truly, TRULY remarkable. In fact, I know of no other cultural dancing costume which has changed quite so significantly. Like many "old school dancers" I was sad to see the more traditional styles replaced, but as a scholar, I was forced to put my own sentimentality aside and examine the phenomena with a neutral eye.
I saw Cahir's column for what it was: a cheap shot at a subculture that no longer conformed to his own ideals. This is unprofessional and inappropriate "journalism" and anyone directing such inflammatory language towards a sport populated by children and adolescents is not someone worth having an argument with, to my mind. But buried beneath all of Cahir's snarky quips, some painful truths about the art/sport ("spart?") were revealed that we in the community should really pay attention to. For example, a comment on Molly Egloff's rebuttal piece pointed to an alleged impropriety in the world of competitive Irish dance: an adjudicator, by the name of Gavin Doherty, who is also the leading costume designer in Northern Ireland. If this is true, (and I make no claims that it is) would this not allege a conflict of interest worthy of our examination?
The other major theme that resurfaced consistently is that old criticism of "this isn't Irish!" Seriously ya'll, this needs to just go away. Like DIE. What most people know for real and for certain about Ireland, it's art and it's culture is minimal and often erroneous. I'm say this not to be offensive! (Though I know many of you will be.) But you should understand that the things YOU associate with Ireland are a part of a manufactured identity. This "Celting up" of Ireland was popularized firstly in Ireland at the turn of the twentieth-century to help create a new identity for the Irish, wholly separate from their Colonizers, Great Britain. This period was called, "the Celtic Revival." This "Celtic" identity was then sold second-hand back to us, the Diaspora suckers, who ate it up like McCann's steel cut oatmeal. The fact that anyone is wearing a costume at all, PERIOD, is a twentieth-cetury invention and in fact, the embroidered interlace (call it "the Irish" in an Irish dance costume) didn't really appear until around the 1920's or later in many parts. The contemporary costume is yet another chapter in the life of a living tradition. It's about a very different thing than what we, or our grandmothers, wore as children. We need to accept that fact, let it live forever in our memories, and move on.
HOWEVER - dancers, this does not let you off the hook! What does all of this stuff mean? If it doesn't matter in the scoring, than why is it necessary? "Because we want to" should not be an acceptable answer. Ditto with the old "confidence" argument. (If you need expensive clothing for confidence, than it's time to re-examine your priorities - just sayin') Think about this question, honestly and completely: What does all of this stuff mean? Is it really necessary? Irish Dance is many things: art, sport, expression of heritage - but it is also Big Business. If anyone is wondering why the "Riverdance" look never caught on completely, just ask a dressmaker. Do you think a bit of simple, unadorned stretch velvet could go for $2500? HECK NO! Your costume is sending a message. Do you REALLY want that message to be, "$$$?"
I interviewed the author and Irish Dance Historian Dr. John Cullinane in 2008. He told me a wonderful story about the significance of costume in Irish dance at the time of Irish War of Independence:
"...when they had a feis on they would assemble at North Monastery, north of here and they would parade in their costumes and the pipers in their kilts and the tri-color and they would parade through the city to wherever the feis was... And that was an extreme expression of Irish national identity because this was during the British occupation. This was the time, they marched down Patrick Street [Cork], and that main street was burned to the ground by the Black and Tans...and yet they were marching in full costume with tri-colors."
Hmmm...Perhaps we are a bit in the woods. Or maybe this is just where we are for right now. Only time will tell, but it's not up to me to judge or fix that. Ladies and gents, consider the gauntlet thrown...
photo credit: Irish Dancing Costumes: Their Origins and Evolutions, Dr. John Cullinane. 1996.